One hundred years after Antonio Gramsci’s arrest, the striking relevance of his ideas and the example set by his own life remain a living legacy that must be reclaimed and defended.
On the evening of November 8, 1926, the police entered the rented room where Gramsci was living in Rome and took him away. He was the General Secretary of the Communist Party of Italy (PCd’I) and a member of parliament, elected two years earlier, but parliamentary immunity no longer counted for anything.
Yet neither internal exile nor subsequent imprisonment in Turi prison, despite his serious health problems, succeeded in preventing Gramsci from thinking and reflecting on the world around him. His notes written during imprisonment were later published as the Prison Notebooks, embodying an extraordinary intellectual effort spanning political strategy, philosophy, history, culture, and literature. This legacy helped make him one of the most widely studied thinkers in the world over the following decades. To mention a particularly curious anecdote, when Brazilian midfielder Sócrates¹ arrived in Italy in the 1980s to play for Fiorentina, he named Gramsci as the Italian he admired most and whose work he intended to study more deeply.
However, the enormous recognition enjoyed by Gramsci’s thought has frequently been accompanied by misleading interpretations that bear little resemblance to reality. Some have emphasized his intellectual achievements precisely to obscure the reality of his political commitment as a communist militant and leader. Others have attempted to interpret his ideas outside Marxism, turning him into a “neutral thinker” or an ordinary democrat. Still others have sought to reduce him to a pop-culture icon with an anti-fascist image. I believe these distortions do a profound injustice to his legacy.
Gramsci was, first and foremost, a communist militant and a Marxist-Leninist. From his experience with L’Ordine Nuovo and the factory councils, through the split at Livorno and the founding of the PCd’I, his political activity was that of a revolutionary who devoted his efforts and his life to the overthrow of capitalism. And the man arrested on November 8, 1926, was precisely that communist leader, that revolutionary, the General Secretary of the PCd’I, at a time when the communists, despite the difficulties they faced, represented the principal threat to the fascist regime.
From his struggle against the reformist and maximalist tendencies that had paralyzed the Italian Socialist Party (PSI), through the Livorno split and the founding of the PCd’I, Gramsci made tremendous efforts to equip the working class not merely with a party, but with a party of the Leninist type. These efforts culminated in the Lyon Congress, which affirmed the party’s working-class character and Leninist organization, emphasizing the importance of organizing in the workplaces. This was no minor matter, because questions of organization are political questions.
How different would the situation be today if Italy had a strong communist party capable of organizing workers where they produce, throwing a wrench into the machinery of war, and turning the tables against precarious employment and the rising cost of living? This question makes the contemporary relevance of Gramsci’s efforts unmistakably clear. It is precisely along these lines that we must work. As we see every day, struggles are certainly not lacking, from strikes to mobilizations against war. But without a force capable of linking these struggles together and bringing them onto the political terrain, they run up against a ceiling imposed by the bourgeois parties.
Working in this direction means accepting a historic responsibility and a task that is far from easy, given the complexity of the present situation. The weakness of the workers’ and communist movement, the fragmentation that followed the liquidation of the Italian Communist Party (PCI), and the long years of opportunism can make the challenges before us appear insurmountable.
Yet the very nature of the society in which we live, still founded on the exploitation of human beings by other human beings, makes the necessity of overthrowing capitalism as urgent as ever. Faced with war, unemployment, precarious employment, and the general deterioration of living conditions, the need to abolish the capitalist system that produces these contradictions becomes impossible to ignore. In this respect, Gramsci, together with Marxism itself, provides us with the tools to understand the present period and to equip ourselves for the struggle against the forces that ultimately determine the unjust and reactionary character of the system in which we live.
This means reclaiming the importance of Gramsci’s concept of the “war of position” as part of a revolutionary strategy capable of confronting contemporary capitalist society, rather than, as is sometimes the case, using it to justify reformist or electoralist approaches. Likewise, the struggle for “hegemony” must be understood as a struggle rooted in class relations and organization, rather than reduced to a mere contest for public consent or an attempt to build vaguely progressive cultural influence within society. These are essential considerations if we wish to safeguard the legacy of Gramsci’s thought and employ it as a useful instrument today.
Exactly one hundred years after his arrest, remembering Gramsci means refusing to retreat in the face of today’s undoubtedly unfavorable conditions. It means refusing to abandon our historic role, working to bring together the most advanced elements of the working class, rebuilding organization in the workplaces, and making steady progress, day after day, through our daily activity, in strengthening our roots within the class. For these advances already contain, in embryonic form, the trenches of the war of position that we must wage to reclaim our future.
Finally, I believe it is important to emphasize that Gramsci’s legacy is not confined to his theoretical contributions and practical political experience. He also stands as a fundamental example of determination and perseverance. His is the story of a man who made a conscious choice about how to live his life. A man who, in an affectionate letter to his mother, wrote that he was prepared to face any sentence:
“Life is like that, very hard, and sometimes children must cause their mothers great sorrow if they wish to preserve their honor and dignity as human beings.”²
And so, behind the bars of a prison cell, he held firmly to his convictions without surrendering to despair. He wrote words that continue to give strength to those of us who, amid countless difficulties, carry forward that same struggle today:
“Even when everything is, or seems to be, lost, we must calmly set to work again, starting from the beginning.”³
Notes
1. L’Unità, June 18, 1984, p. 13.
2. Antonio Gramsci, letter to his mother, May 10, 1928, written from San Vittore prison in Milan, shortly before his transfer to Rome for trial before the Special Tribunal.
3. Antonio Gramsci, letter to his brother Carlo, September 12, 1927, written from San Vittore prison in Milan while awaiting trial.
* Gianmarco Chilelli is the General Secretary of the Communist Front (Italy)
